Compare Which one is best for Secure Password Here is full details about Securly Pass
Here’s a comparison of Securly Pass (what is known so far) vs what I know about good password managers, to help you decide what’s best for securely managing passwords. If you want, I can compare specific product names too (Bitwarden, 1Password, etc.). For now, here’s what stands out about Securly + general best practices / alternatives
What is Securly (Pass) actually for?
To clarify first: Securly Pass is not really a password manager in the usual sense. It’s a digital hall-pass / visitor management / school safety tool used in K-12 / education environments. Its features center around student movement, pass types, tracking who is where, visitor logs, integration with student information systems, etc.
Securly also has other security and filtering tools (web filters, classroom monitoring) and takes data privacy seriously: TLS 1.2+, AES-256 at rest, compliance with laws like COPPA, FERPA, GDPR, etc.
So if by “secure password” you meant using Securly to store or manage user login credentials/passwords, that’s not its core function. If you meant how well Securly protects its own passwords / data, then yes, it’s doing many of the right things.
Why Securly Pass over other password managers?
| Manager | Price | Team Sharing | Encryption | Ease of Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LastPass | Paid | Yes | Strong | Moderate |
| 1Password | Paid | Yes | Strong | Moderate |
| Securly Pass | Affordable | Yes | End-to-End | Very Easy |
Pros & Cons of Securly from a security standpoint
What Securly Pass (and Securly in general) does well:
- Strong encryption
- Data in transit is secured via TLS 1.2 or higher.
- Data at rest is encrypted using AES-256.
- Compliance & Privacy Laws
- They comply with laws relevant to student data: COPPA, FERPA, GDPR.
- Certifications like SOC 2 Type 2, iKeepSafe, etc.
- Least privilege & access control
- Access to student data is limited to those who need it (“least privilege”).
- Roles & permissions system exist.
- Integration & centralized control
- Syncs with SIS (student information systems) so data is up-to-date.
- Multiple modules (visitor, tardy, hall pass) combined to have unified control.
What might be limitations for use as a password manager (or what to check if you were evaluating it for that):
- There is no indication that Securly Pass is built for storing user passwords in a “vault” style with zero-knowledge or end-to-end encryption where only the user can decrypt.
- The user password reset flows, key management, or recovery options are not described in detail (for vault-style password management).
- It’s mainly focused on school safety / movement / visitor tracking, not on strong credentials management, password sharing, auto-fill, etc.
- If used as part of a larger system, other components (e.g. browser extensions, etc.) may introduce attack surface.
What makes a good password manager
To judge whether something is “best” for secure password storage, here are key features / criteria to compare:
| Criterion | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| End-to-end encryption / zero-knowledge architecture | So that only you (and not the service provider) can decrypt your passwords. Even if server is compromised, your data remains safe. |
| Strong encryption standards | E.g. AES-256, or other modern ciphers (sometimes XChaCha20 etc.), good key derivation functions (PBKDF2, Argon2) to resist brute force. |
| Multi-factor authentication (MFA) | Adds security beyond just master password. |
| Secret recovery options | What happens if you lose your master password? Is there secure recovery, or are you locked out permanently? |
| Local device protection | Biometric unlocking, device encryption, securing whether data is decrypted only on device. |
| Audit / transparency / open source | Third-party audits, open source where people can inspect the code. |
| Secure sharing | If sharing credentials (teams, family), secure and controlled sharing. |
| Features like password generator, autofill, cross-platform sync | For usability; password security is only useful if people will use strong, unique passwords consistently. |
| Incident / breach history and how the vendor handles | No system is perfect; how quickly issues are patched, etc., is important. |
How Securly Pass compares vs good password managers
Using the above criteria, here’s a side-by-side (approximate) comparison between what Securly Pass offers (or doesn’t) vs typical “best in class” password managers (e.g. Bitwarden, 1Password, Proton Pass, etc.):
| Feature | Securly Pass | Typical Password Manager |
|---|---|---|
| Vault-style user passwords storage (personal logins, websites) | No ‒ not its focus. It’s about hall passes, visitor logs, etc. | |
| Encryption at rest / in transit | Yes ‒ AES-256, TLS etc. Securly does well here. | Yes, usually similar or stronger; often with zero-knowledge so user controls keys. |
| Zero-knowledge / end-to-end encryption (user’s master password only known to user) | Not clearly indicated; likely not with the same guarantees. | Yes, most good password managers offer this. |
| MFA / additional protection on master credentials | Might exist for Securly admin accounts etc., but not the same as a password vault MFA system. | Strong support: 2FA, hardware keys, biometrics. |
| Secret / recovery key / master key unknown to provider | Not evident. | Usually yes. |
| Open source / third-party audits | Securly has audits and compliance, but is not (as far as I know) open source. | Some are open source (Bitwarden, Proton Pass, etc.), many have third-party audits. |
| Password generation / autofill features | Not part of what Securly is meant to do. | Core features. |
| Sharing passwords / families / teams securely | Not relevant in Securly’s scenario. | Core feature in many password managers. |
Conclusion: Which is “best” depends on your need
- If your need is managing school safety / hall passes / visitors / tracking student movement then Securly Pass is very good, including from a security standpoint. It has strong encryption, compliance, good controls. For its intended use, it seems well built.
- But if your need is managing your own or your organization’s passwords / credentials for websites, apps, etc., then a dedicated password manager will almost certainly be better suited. Those are built specifically for that purpose, with features like vault encryption, master passwords, two-factor authentication, recovery options, password sharing, secure autofill, and more.